By Chet Yarbrough
Written by: Steven Brill
Narrated by: Dan Woren
“America’s Bitter Pill” is a policy wonk’s dream and an American citizen’s nightmare. It reveals the role of money and politics in American government. Steven Brill indicts a political process that seems freighted with more venal self-interest than good will. Brill overwhelms readers, which are not policy wonks, with disgusting political backroom deals and entrenched private and non-profit interests that affect the federal legislative process. The disgust comes from the distortion of the most important legislation passed by the American’ Federal Government since the New Deal.
How can one argue that the private sector with an “invisible hand” is adequately providing health care to a general public in the richest country in the world?
Too many Americans have no health coverage because they cannot afford it. All one has to do is ask how many Americans do not go to the doctor because they cannot afford the visit and do not have insurance against catastrophic illness. Even the “god” of conservative economics, Friedrich von Hayek, believed government had a responsibility to provide “…a comprehensive system of social insurance in providing for those common hazards of life against which few can make adequate provision.”
What Brill shows is that the value of high profits to private and nonprofit insurance and medical facilities is more important than offering reasonably priced health care to the general public. What every special interest lobbied for in the Affordable Care Act depended on improving or maintaining profit. “America’s Bitter Pill”, the Affordable Care Act, is laced with greed. The Affordable Care Act has extended insurance to more people in the United States than ever before, but it continues to rankle knowledgeable Americans because it is based on the false belief that it will cure an incurable disease, human greed.
Many politicians hid behind the mythic part of an “invisible hand” to rationalize their cave-in to special interests. Hiding is shown to be non-partisan by Brill because it includes both Democrats and Republicans. The mythic part of the “invisible hand” is the belief that self-interest is always in the best interest of the public. President Obama chose the only path he could have for any chance of passing an Affordable Care Act.
The only voting majority in America’s bicameral Congress to have any chance for consensus is shown by Brill to be dependent on acceptance by insurance companies, hospitals, the pharmaceutical industry, and ancillary medical service equipment manufacturers.
An optimist chooses to believe America’s flawed legislative system will, in the long run, serve its public better than any other known form of government. The optimist believes the Affordable Care Act will be improved over time and will mitigate increased health care costs. The pessimist believes the Affordable Care Act is a boondoggle. The pessimist believes American government is accelerating its move toward tyranny. A realist suggests the Affordable Care Act is Democracy in action.